Please make sure you put in the correct shared SSL path found here.
Please do not forget the final slash at the end of your user name.
If you still can't get this to work, please contact HostGator via live chat, phone, or email support@hostgator.com with your account details.
The related articles below may also be useful to you.
cPanel is a popular web hosting control panel that helps you manage your hosting account and assists you in creating web sites, managing e-mail addresses, & installing applications to a server.